Justice Scalia died. I still don't like him. And that's OK.

I didn’t like Antonin Scalia.

Photo by Alex Wong/Getty Images.

I never met him, but boy did I not like the guy.

I think most of his votes on the Supreme Court made the country worse.

I think too many of them made ordinary people’s lives more difficult.

He said some pretty horrible things about gay people. In Lawrence v. Texas, the case that ruled sodomy laws unconstitutional, he made jokes about “flagpole sitting” during oral arguments.

In that case, he argued in his dissent that because “many Americans do not want persons who openly engage in homosexual conduct as partners in their business, as scoutmasters for their children, [and] as teachers in their children’s schools,” that was reason enough to keep Texas’ sodomy ban intact.

He called the Voting Rights Act a “racial entitlement.”

His dissent in Planned Parenthood v. Casey — the 1992 decision that affirmed a woman’s right to chose — alludes to Nazism and slavery.

His last vote — in a lawsuit brought against the EPA by 29 states — made it more difficult for the United States to enforce regulations designed to combat climate change, one of the greatest existential threats to humanity in the 21st century.

Literally, the last act of his professional life was to make it harder to prevent global ecological catastrophe.

Like an actual supervillain.

Pretty much. Photo by J.J./Wikimedia Commons.

There are a lot of reasons not to like the guy.

And now he’s dead.

I’m sad he’s dead. He had a family, who must be reeling. He had friends, who are certainly devastated. His fellow justices liked and respected him. Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, his ideological opponent in every way, was reportedly one of his closest friends.

I’m sad he’s dead. And I think his professional legacy is a highly destructive one.

I’m sad he’s dead. And I still don’t like him.

There’s no “but.” It’s just “and.”

I think that’s fine.

It’s complicated, and I don’t think there’s anything wrong with that.

Photo by Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images.

I can be angry at him for steering our society toward more racism, homophobia, and sexism without being happy he’s dead.

I can be excited that someone new will replace him on the court without being happy he’s dead.

Just because someone dies doesn’t mean you have to stop disagreeing with them. And disagreeing with them doesn’t mean you’re glad they’re not alive anymore. When public figures die, it’s natural to want to assess their records. It’s not too soon to criticize them.

It’s more respectful to his legacy, honestly — to remember it clearly, the way he laid it down.

“It would be not much use to have a First Amendment, for example, if the freedom of speech included only what some future generation wanted it to include,” he once said. He’d almost certainly support the right to call him out on his worst tendencies, even after death.

It wasn’t all negative, of course. It never is.

Photo by Paul Morigi/Getty Images.

There were a couple of moments where he came down on the right side of history, mostly in favor of people’s right to free expression.

He was a terrific writer, even if frequently wrote odious things. He was funny.

“The Supreme Court of the United States has descended from the disciplined reasoning of John Marshall and Joseph Story to the mystical aphorisms of the fortune cookie,” he wrote in a footnote to his stinging dissent in Obergefell v. Hodges, the case that finally made marriage equality the law of the land in 2015.

Unlike many political figures, he knew how to take a joke.

In my opinion, Scalia was a pretty terrible Supreme Court justice. But you know what? I don’t think he’d really care how much I couldn’t stand him. His opinion, when he was alive, counted way more than mine when it mattered.

He was a giant. He was a huge jerk. He was human.

Rest in peace.

Source link

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This
10 Alternatives To The Big Bang Theory
10 Strange Facts About Twins
10 Accidental Medical Discoveries
10 Racist Medical Experiments
People In London Try In-N-Out For The First Time
A photographer spent 3 weeks among the mammoth pirates. This is what he saw.
100 Most Hilarious Ironic Pictures of All Time
What If Disney Princesses Were Fighters • Elsa Vs. Snow White
Cats Need An Update
Dropped a glass while doing the dishes and it showed me the point of impact.
No Preview
After only 12 hours William Murray Line is nearly gone (2 Photos)
Do Not Eat My Lunch
Old People Fails | “Retirement Fails” By FailArmy 2016
Fails of the Week 1 October 2016 || Fail Army
Best Funny Kid Fails Compilation Part 2 | FailArmy 2016
Fails of the Week 2 October 2016 || Fail Army
Funny Amusement Park Videos from the JukinVideo Vault
Funny Husky Videos from the JukinVideo Vault
Girl Confused by Sliding Glass Door
Rope Swing Foot Caught Fail
Kim Kardashian shows off bra in see-through top while bowling with Kourtney and Khloe
Every inch the icon: Model and mother-of-one Carolyn Murphy, 41, shows off a VERY youthful physique as she strips down to her lingerie for sultry Town & Country shoot
Gloria Vanderbilt was 17 when she fell for 36-year-old Howard Hughes
'Scouse Pammie’ spends £20,000 on surgery to look like Pamela Anderson